Read in English | Lire en Français | Lesen auf Deutsch

More Shades Do Not Always Mean More Growth

For beauty brands entering the European market, one challenge is becoming increasingly important:

Having more eyebrow pencil shades does not always lead to higher sales.

Many brands believe that a wider shade range means better consumer coverage.

As a result, they plan to launch:

• 12 shades

• 18 shades

• 30+ shades

However, after entering the market, many brands discover that excessive SKUs create unexpected operational problems.

Common challenges include:

✓ Slow-moving shades creating inventory pressure
✓ More complicated production planning
✓ Higher packaging and labeling management costs
✓ Marketing resources being spread across too many products

With the introduction of the EU PPWR (Packaging and Packaging Waste Regulation), beauty brands now need to think beyond product variety.

They must also consider:

• Packaging efficiency

• Supply chain flexibility

• Product portfolio optimization

For eyebrow pencil brands, the future is not about creating the largest number of shades.

It is about building a smarter eyebrow pencil SKU strategy.

As a finished makeup product supplier, GUER YOUNG helps beauty brands optimize product structures, improve supply chain efficiency, and create market-ready cosmetic collections.Why Too Many Eyebrow Pencil SKUs Create Business Challenges

1. More SKUs Mean Higher Inventory Risk

Every additional eyebrow pencil shade requires:

• Separate raw materials

• Additional production planning

• Individual packaging inventory

• Warehouse management

For emerging beauty brands, predicting the demand of every shade can be difficult.

Some shades may become best sellers, while others may remain in inventory for months.

This creates:

• Higher inventory costs

• Slower cash flow

• Less flexibility for future product launches

A successful beauty brand does not need the most SKUs.

It needs the right SKUs.

2. Multiple Shades Increase Supply Chain Complexity

Eyebrow pencils are small beauty products, but shade management requires precision.

Each shade may involve:

• Different labels

• Different packaging information

• Separate production batches

• Additional product documentation

As SKU numbers increase, operational management becomes more complicated.

For brands preparing to enter Europe, a complex product structure can slow down market expansion.

3. EU PPWR Creates New Packaging Challenges

The EU PPWR cosmetics regulation is encouraging brands to reduce unnecessary packaging and improve packaging efficiency.

For eyebrow pencil brands, a large number of shades often means:

• More packaging versions

• More material management

• Higher development costs

Therefore, optimizing SKU numbers has become an important strategy for brands looking to grow sustainably in Europe.

Case Study: How a Paris Beauty Brand Reduced 18 Eyebrow Pencil SKUs to 6 Core Shades

A rising beauty brand from Paris was preparing to launch a natural-look eyebrow pencil collection in Europe.

Their original plan was:

18 eyebrow pencil shades + multiple packaging combinations

The brand believed that more shades would help them reach more consumers.

However, during product preparation, they discovered several challenges:

• High initial inventory investment

• Uncertain demand for some shades

• More complicated packaging management

• Increased pressure from EU PPWR requirements

Product Analysis

Instead of moving directly into production, GUER YOUNG first analyzed the brand’s product structure and consumer demand.

The research showed that many shades appeared different visually, but actual purchasing behavior showed significant overlap.

Consumers did not necessarily need dozens of similar shades.

They needed a simple way to find the right shade quickly.

SKU Optimization Solution

Based on the market analysis, the product line was redesigned:

From:

18 SKUs

To:

6 core eyebrow pencil shades

Including:

• Natural Brown

• Dark Brown

• Ash Brown

• Soft Black

• Warm Brown

• Cool Brown

These six shades covered the main consumer groups while reducing inventory risk.

Product Portfolio Optimization

Reducing SKUs does not mean reducing product opportunities.

A stronger strategy is to optimize the overall makeup product portfolio.

The brand introduced:

Eyebrow Pencil + Brush Set

Providing a complete application solution.

Brow Product Collection

Creating a stronger product ecosystem with complementary products.

Limited Testing Shades

Keeping selected shades for future market testing.

This approach allowed the brand to maintain innovation without creating unnecessary inventory pressure.

How to Build an Effective Eyebrow Pencil SKU Strategy

1. Focus on Hero SKUs First

Instead of launching too many shades at the beginning, brands should identify their strongest products.

Hero SKUs should focus on:

• High-demand colors

• Repeat purchase potential

• Shades suitable for multiple markets

Concentrating resources on key products helps brands build stronger market recognition.

2. Create a Smart Shade Architecture

A successful shade system should have clear categories.

Core Shades

Designed for everyday consumers.

Examples:

Natural Brown and Dark Brown.

Specialty Shades

Designed for specific consumer preferences.

Examples:

Ash Brown and Cool Brown.

Testing Shades

Used for future expansion and market research.

This structure allows brands to balance consumer choice and operational efficiency.

3. Build Value Through Product Structure

Successful beauty brands are not defined by how many products they have.

They are defined by how efficiently their products meet consumer needs.

An optimized makeup product portfolio can help brands:

✓ Reduce inventory costs
✓ Improve supply chain efficiency
✓ Simplify packaging management
✓ Strengthen product positioning

The Future of Beauty Brands: Efficiency Over Quantity

In the EU PPWR era, beauty competition is moving from product quantity to product efficiency.

Eyebrow pencil brands need to shift from:

“ How many shades can we launch? ”

to:

“ Which products truly deserve investment? ”

A smart SKU strategy helps brands:

• Reduce operational risks

• Improve inventory turnover

• Optimize packaging management

• Build stronger market positioning

Reducing unnecessary SKUs does not mean reducing opportunities.

It means creating a more focused and profitable product line.

GUER YOUNG supports global beauty brands with product planning, SKU optimization, and finished makeup solutions designed for international markets.

If your brand is developing eyebrow pencils, eye makeup, or a new cosmetic collection, the right product structure can be more valuable than simply adding more shades.